I don't know if you guys have Edie's down there, but their Moose Tracks ROCKS.

Alas, my very favorite peanut butter cup used to be Ben & Jerry's, but I think they discontinued it. :(

Mmmm. Which reminds me, I also love Phish Food. B&J's has an EXCELLENT chunk to cream ratio.

Man, I wish you guys had Stewart's Convenience Stores down there -- they have cheap peanut butter cup that is EXCELLENT. DOWN WITH regional ice cream treats!