I just don't find S5 DB chubby. Maybe because I can't help but think of that period as just the transition between the comparitively slim body he had in say, S1 of BtVS, and the great big beefcake body he has now; the extra weight is just filling out. I dunno.

To me the plot of S4 completely trumps BtVS S2. But that's because S4 OWNS me.

And hi there!